Looking for the perfect mascara can feel like an endless search. Do your lashes need length? More volume? A formula that doesn’t leave smudges under your eyes? The list of challenges goes on. If you feel stuck choosing between traditional mascaras and the increasingly popular tubing mascaras, you’re not alone. Maybe you're also making that crucial transition into clean beauty products and want to make informed choices. Either way, this blog is here to guide you.

By the end of this post, you’ll not only understand the hype around tubing mascaras but also learn how top clean formulas like Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions and Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara fare against each other. Plus, we'll break down why clean tubing mascaras might just revolutionize your lash game.

The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

What is Tubing Mascara and Why Is Everyone Talking About It?

Tubing mascaras are the beauty industry’s best-kept secret (well, maybe not anymore). Unlike traditional mascaras, which coat your lashes with pigment, tubing mascaras use advanced polymers to wrap each lash in a "tube" of color. These microscopic tubes not only lengthen and volumize your lashes but also come with some impressive benefits over regular mascaras.

Instead of smudging or flaking throughout the day, tubing mascaras lock in place. And when it’s time to remove them? Simply rinse with warm water and watch those little tubes slide off effortlessly—no harmful removers required.

For beauty enthusiasts who struggle with clumping, flaking, or achieving the perfect lash length, tubing mascara offers a real solution. Combine this with a clean formula, and you’ve got a game-changer.

Why Use Clean Mascaras?

Clean beauty is more than just a trend; it’s a commitment to using safe, eco-friendly products free from potentially harmful ingredients. Conventional mascaras often include parabens, synthetic fragrances, and harsh preservatives that can irritate sensitive eyes or cause long-term health concerns.

Clean mascaras steer away from these harmful ingredients, offering you peace of mind—without compromising performance. And when your clean mascara is also tubing-based? You might find yourself wondering why you didn’t make the switch sooner.

SHOP CLEAN TUBING MASCARA

Which Mascara is Best for Volume and Length?

If you’re looking for a mascara that delivers both incredible volume and impressive length, it really comes down to your priorities and personal preferences. For those who love that bold, dramatic look with noticeable length and thickness, the Tower 28 MakeWaves Tubing Mascara might be your go-to. It’s especially great if you want a clean, modern product that’s also gentle on your eyes. The formulation is designed to lift and volumize while still adding definition, making it a versatile choice for everyday wear or glam looks.

However, if you’re seeking dramatic volume and still want the benefits of easy removal and long-lasting wear, weighing in the pros and cons of other tubing mascaras might be worthwhile. It’s all about testing what works best for your unique lashes—sometimes it takes a little experimentation to find the perfect match!

Reviewing Popular Tubing Mascaras in Clean Beauty

Here’s how four top clean tubing mascaras stack up:

Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions Tubing Mascara

If you’ve seen the ads, you already know Thrive is a cult favorite, it is my favorite too, but not to sweat a lot in because I can get some transfer, but it should be noted I teach spin and get really sweaty, I have no transfer outside the spin room or any other workout! Thrive tubing mascara is popular for a reason—it delivers serious length without clumping, see my photo above. Its formula contains nourishing ingredients like shea butter and orchid stem cell complex, designed to condition your lashes while building volume.

Pros:

Dramatic length and definition
Smudge-proof and long-lasting
Infused with lash-nourishing ingredient

Cons:

It’s on the higher end of the price spectrum
Some reviewers find the formula slightly heavy on short lashes

Tarte Tartelette XL Tubing Mascara

Tarte has long been a trusted name in clean beauty, and their Tubing Mascara doesn’t disappoint. It excels in creating that fluttery, natural lash look. This one I also love, and it really packs a punch! A tad lighter than Thrive, but still really amazing!

Pros:

Lightweight formula that’s buildable
Vegan and cruelty-free
Perfect for an everyday look

Cons:

Lengthening may not be as dramatic compared to Thrive
May require extra layers for bold volume

Jane Iredale Lash Fixation Tubing Mascara

Jane Iredale’s mascara offers dual benefits by acting as both a tint and a lash treatment. Rich in clean, nourishing ingredients like algae extract and panthenol, it’s perfect for those who want to combine lash health with beauty.

Pros:

Conditions lashes while creating volume
Great for sensitive eyes
Offers a subtle, elegant finish

Cons:

Not as bold as other tubing mascaras
Limited color options

Tower 28 MakeWaves Tubing Mascara

Known for their minimalist aesthetic and clean ingredients, Tower 28’s MakeWaves mascara is designed for versatility. It separates, lengthens, and volumizes in just a few effortless swipes. This was lighter than all the others mentioned above so if you don’t like thicker lashes with a lot of mascara but more natural, this one may be perfect for you.

Pros:

Suitable for contact lens wearers
Adds both volume and lift
Fun, modern packaging

Cons:

Might need reapplication for extra dramatic looks, I felt this one definitely took more work to apply and had a tad lighter feeling compared to the Thrive.
Slight learning curve with the brush for even application

Why Tubing Mascaras Are Great for Lash Dimension and Length

If your lashes are naturally short or sparse, tubing mascaras can be a total game-changer. The unique formula evenly coats each lash, adding impressive length and a thicker appearance without clumping. Better yet, the durability ensures you won’t have to deal with mid-day smudges or panda eyes.

Regular Clean Mascaras vs. Tubing Mascaras

Pros of Regular Clean Mascaras:

Diverse range of formulas for different needs
Often include nourishing, plant-based ingredients
Suitable for traditional makeup looks

Cons of Regular Clean Mascaras:

More prone to smudging or flaking
Require makeup removers, which can irritate skin or eyes
May struggle to deliver the same "wow" factor as tubing mascaras

Pros of Tubing Mascaras:

Effortless removal— just warm water, no scrubbing
Ideal for long days or special events (no smudging, no flaking)
Excellent for lengthening and defining lashes
Minimal irritation, even for the most sensitive eyes

Cons of Tubing Mascaras:

Can be pricier than traditional mascaras
May not deliver the same dramatic volume as some regular mascaras
Requires precision for even application

Honorable Mentions for Other Clean Tubing Mascaras

If you're exploring more options for clean and effective tubing mascaras, here are a few standout picks worth considering:

Beauty Pie Wrap Star Tubing Mascara: This mascara offers a seamless combination of length and volume with an ultra-clean formula, perfect for everyday use.
Hourglass Caution Extreme Mascara: Known for its intensity, this tubing mascara delivers bold, dramatic lashes without the worry of smudging or flaking.

These options ensure you have plenty of choices to find the perfect mascara suited to your needs!

Who Should Choose Tubing Mascara?

Tubing mascaras cater to anyone who wants low-maintenance lashes that look polished and defined all day. They’re especially ideal if:

You have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses.
You need a smudge-proof solution for long days or humid weather.
You want to skip harsh makeup removers and simplify your routine.
You struggle to achieve noticeable length or dimension with traditional mascaras.

Clean tubing mascaras combine the best of two worlds—safe, eco-conscious formulas and game-changing lash technology. Whether you’re drawn to the bold length of Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions or the versatility of Tower 28’s MakeWaves mascara, there’s a perfect fit for you.

If you’ve been frustrated with clumping, smudging, or time-intensive removal, now’s the time to make the switch. Find your perfect clean tubing mascara and transform the way you do lashes!

To have more wellness tips sent to you directly, sign up here for my weekly newsletter including workouts, wellness tips, healthy recipes and more!

Shop the Post

A Favorite Post >>>

I love helping my clients let go of painful experiences to help them rebuild trust, self-confidence, self-worth and belief in themselves by addressing the root causes with subconscious change. The tool I use is called PSYCH-K®, and is a quick, pain-free and completely safe way to reprogram your subconscious and to create lasting change for once and for all.

Within my holistic practice, we help you create a lasting self-care practice to regulate your nervous system in your day to day-to-day life, so you can always hear and follow your whispers, instead of the big Mac truck.

If you’re ready to stop dimming your light, start making easy decisions with confidence, and follow through with what you want to achieve, while trusting your intuition, you can easily set up a free conversation with me.

>>>To Book Integrative Energetic Healing Services, click here

Tubing Mascaras vs. Regular Clean Mascaras: Which One is Right for You?